Explainers  /  5 of 20

How loss to liquidation works

Net loss over all the principal that has left a group of loans, and why paydown from before a loan entered its trust still counts.

Loss to liquidation answers one question about a group of loans: of all the principal that has left the loans so far, how much was lost? We build it here from five made-up loans, then run the same arithmetic on the prime auto loans in our data.

Five loans

All five were made in January 2023. Ben and Eli were already paying before their trust bought them: the trust first reports Eli in month 7 and Ben in month 9. Dev stops paying after month 6, the lender charges off his balance in month 9, and the car sells at auction for a recovery in month 14. Cara pays off early in month 20.

Loan Original Monthly principal First reported Owed at month 12 Owed at month 24
Ava $20,000 $400 month 1 $15,200 $10,400
Ben $30,000 $500 month 9 $24,000 $18,000
Cara $25,000 $500 month 1 $19,000 $0
Dev $12,000 $300 month 1 $0 $0
Eli $18,000 $300 month 7 $14,400 $10,800

The rate is built from two numbers:

  • Net loss is what was charged off less what was recovered later.
  • Liquidation is every dollar of principal that left the loans, whether it was repaid or charged off.

Loss to liquidation is net loss divided by liquidation. Both run from the day each loan was made, and a loan counts from the month its trust first reports it.

Month 12, in four steps

Loan Paid down by month 12
Ava $4,800
Ben $6,000
Cara $6,000
Dev $1,800
Eli $3,600
  1. Add up what was paid down: $4,800 + $6,000 + $6,000 + $1,800 + $3,600 = $22,200. Ben and Eli count with what they paid before joining.
  2. Add the charge-offs to get liquidation: $22,200 paid down + $10,200 charged off = $32,400
  3. Net loss = charged off - recovered: $10,200 - $0 = $10,200
  4. Divide net loss by liquidation: $10,200 / $32,400 = 31.5%

Same steps at month 24

Loan Paid down by month 24
Ava $9,600
Ben $12,000
Cara $25,000
Dev $1,800
Eli $7,200
  • Paid down: $55,600 (Cara's early payoff counts: it is principal repaid)
  • Liquidation: $55,600 + $10,200 = $65,800
  • Net loss: $10,200 - $6,000 = $4,200
  • Loss to liquidation: $4,200 / $65,800 = 6.4%

Five loans with one charge-off exaggerate the rate. A real vintage holds hundreds of thousands of loans.

Trap 1: count paydown from the day the loan was made

Ben and Eli repaid $5,800 before their trust first reported them. That principal was repaid, so it belongs in the denominator. Leave it out and the rate looks worse than it was:

Denominator Month 12 Month 24
Only what the trust reported $10,200 / $26,600 = 38.3% $4,200 / $60,000 = 7.0%
Everything repaid since the loan was made $10,200 / $32,400 = 31.5% $4,200 / $65,800 = 6.4%

Prime auto loans usually enter a trust some months after they were made, so this matters in real data. Our August 2026 deck counted only the paydown the trust reported, along with an older net-loss calculation, and showed 2022 Q2 at 2.1% by month 24 instead of 1.1%.

Trap 2: leave an age blank until every loan has reached it

Our data runs through September 2026. The newest quarter, 2025 Q2, includes loans made in June 2025, which are only 16 months old. So 2025 Q2 shows month 12 and stops; month 18 stays blank until every loan in the quarter can have reached it.

Combining groups: add the dollars, then divide

Groups of loans are combined by adding their dollars first, so a group with more principal counts for more.

Group Net loss Liquidation Rate
Our five loans $4,200 $65,800 6.4%
A bigger vintage $1,000 $200,000 0.50%
Added together $5,200 $265,800 2.0%

Averaging the two rates would give 3.4%, as if both groups were the same size.

The real numbers

Each cell of the triangle is the same division, over prime auto loans (FICO 660-900 at origination) made in one quarter, at one age, across every issuer in our data.

Vintage Net loss by month 24 Liquidation by month 24 Loans counted Loss to liquidation
2020 Q3 $23.5 million $5.30 billion 395,904 0.44%
2022 Q2 $61.4 million $5.67 billion 386,725 1.1%

Prime loans made in 2022 Q2 lost 2.4 times as much as those made in 2020 Q3, at the same age.

Recap

  • Loss to liquidation = net loss / liquidation.
  • Net loss = charged off - recovered. Liquidation = paid down + charged off.
  • Combine loans and groups by adding dollars, then dividing.
  • Trap 1: paydown before the trust bought a loan still counts.
  • Trap 2: leave an age blank until every loan in the group has reached it.

Where to see it

Source: LoanTape, SEC Form ABS-EE loan-level data, through September 2026.