Explainers  /  13 of 20

How an issuer is read against its own history

Where an issuer's latest number sits within the range of its own past.

An issuer's latest number, ranked within the range of its own past. A lender to subprime borrowers always has higher delinquency than a lender to prime borrowers, so ranking lenders against each other mostly tells you who they lend to. Ranking each one against its own past tells you whether something has changed.

The formula

  • Rank = (earlier quarters below the latest + half of any ties) ÷ number of earlier quarters, as a percentile from 0 to 100. A latest number above every earlier one shows as 99.
  • Below its range: under the 15th percentile. Usual range: 15th to 85th. Above its range: over the 85th.
  • The number ranked here is the same early delinquency rate as the FICO corridors: the original balance of loans 30 or more days late, or charged off, within six months ÷ the original balance of the quarter's loans.

Worked example: three lenders

Lender Lends to Eight earlier quarters, sorted Latest Earlier quarters lower Rank
Maple Auto Prime 0.20%, 0.25%, 0.30%, 0.35%, 0.40%, 0.45%, 0.60%, 0.70% 0.65% 7 of 8 P88 Above its range
Birch Credit Subprime 9.0%, 9.8%, 10.5%, 11.2%, 11.9%, 12.6%, 13.4%, 14.8% 10.1% 2 of 8 P25 Usual range
Cedar Finance Subprime 4.2%, 4.6%, 4.9%, 5.1%, 5.3%, 5.5%, 5.8%, 6.0% 3.9% 0 of 8 P0 Below its range

Ranked against each other, Birch Credit looks worst at 10.1%. Against its own past it is at P25, its usual range. Maple Auto's 0.65% is small, but higher than 7 of its 8 earlier quarters: 7 ÷ 8 = 87.5%, P88, above its range.

The real numbers

Every issuer with at least 6 earlier quarters and 100 loans in its latest full quarter, loans made since 2017, loans only:

Issuer 30+ late or charged off within six months Rank in its own past Range Earlier quarters
Harley-Davidson 0.59% P99 Above 26
Drive 18.9% P90 Above 30
Ally 0.28% P79 Usual 34
CarMax 1.2% P77 Usual 35
Mercedes-Benz 0.34% P71 Usual 28
World Omni 0.63% P66 Usual 35
Honda 0.02% P66 Usual 35
Santander 9.4% P57 Usual 35
Capital One 0.00% P48 Usual 22
Carvana 0.93% P45 Usual 22
Exeter 10.0% P42 Usual 26
Hyundai 0.06% P40 Usual 35
Toyota 0.00% P37 Usual 35
GM Financial 0.34% P34 Usual 35
Nissan 0.00% P34 Usual 35
Fifth Third 0.00% P33 Usual 6
BMW 0.00% P31 Usual 26
Ford 0.49% P26 Usual 35
Bridgecrest 7.4% P25 Usual 12

Each issuer's latest full quarter: 2025 Q4 for most; Harley-Davidson 2025 Q1, Drive 2025 Q3, Fifth Third 2022 Q4.

Harley-Davidson ranks highest: 0.59% for loans made in 2025 Q1, P99 of its own past. Drive has the highest rate, 18.9%, at P90.

Santander's past includes 2020 and 2021, when loans went bad unusually rarely. Its latest quarter, 9.4%, ranks P57 of its past; leave those two years out and it ranks P44.

Common pitfalls

  1. Reading the rank as the size. A rank says a number is unusual for that lender, not that it is big. Keep the rate beside it: Harley-Davidson at 0.59% and Drive at 18.9% are both above their usual ranges, but they describe very different pools.
  2. Short histories. With eight earlier quarters a rank can only take nine values, 12.5 points apart. The deck ranks an issuer only with at least 6 earlier quarters and 100 loans in its latest quarter.
  3. Eras in the past. Loans made in 2020 and 2021 went bad unusually rarely, which pulls an issuer's past down. A lender that changes who it lends to also moves against its own past without its underwriting getting worse for any one kind of borrower.

Where to see it

  • State of Auto deck (August 2026): page 15 (this ranking), page 16 (the same ranking for the share of loans charged off within 12 months, counted by loans) and pages 107 and 109 (the Extension Default Rate of the latest three months against each issuer's previous 24 months, prime and subprime).
  • Dashboard: Delinquency, then Delinquency History, for an issuer's delinquency over time.

Source: LoanTape, SEC Form ABS-EE loan-level data, through September 2026.