Explainers  /  4 of 20

How cumulative net loss and loss severity work

How charge-offs and recoveries net into cumulative net loss, and how it splits into how often loans default and how much each one loses.

Cumulative net loss is the share of the money lent to a group of borrowers that has been lost for good, after the cars behind the bad loans are sold. Loss severity is the share of a charged-off loan that is lost after the car is sold.

The formulas

  • Cumulative net loss = (everything charged off so far - everything recovered so far) / the original balance of all the loans in the group.
  • Loss severity = (charged off - recovered) / charged off, for the loans that were charged off.

A charge-off is the balance a lender writes off when it gives up on a loan, usually after 90 or more days without a payment. A recovery is what comes back later, mostly from selling the repossessed car.

Eight loans

Eight made-up car loans, all made in the same month, $200,000 in total. Each pays down its balance in equal monthly amounts over five years.

Loan Original balance What happened by month 24 Charged off Recovered
Gus $34,000 Paid every month - -
Hana $26,000 Paid every month - -
Ivy $18,000 Stopped paying after month 5; charged off in month 9; car sold $16,500 $10,300
Jon $31,000 Paid every month - -
Kai $12,000 Stopped paying after month 9; charged off in month 13; car sold $10,200 $3,900
Lea $36,000 Paid off in month 18 - -
Max $37,000 Paid every month - -
Noor $6,000 Stopped paying after month 13; charged off in month 17; car sold $4,700 $1,000
Total $200,000 $31,400 $15,200

Cumulative net loss

  • Charged off: $16,500 + $10,200 + $4,700 = $31,400
  • Recovered: $10,300 + $3,900 + $1,000 = $15,200
  • Net loss: $31,400 - $15,200 = $16,200
  • Cumulative net loss: $16,200 / $200,000 = 8.1%

Lea paid off early and nobody lost money on her loan, but her balance stays in the denominator: the rate is over everything that was lent. Eight loans with three charge-offs make a far higher rate than a real group of hundreds of thousands of loans would.

Loss severity

Loan Car age when bought Loan-to-value Charged off Recovered Lost Severity
Ivy 1 year 85% $16,500 $10,300 $6,200 37.6%
Kai 4 years 110% $10,200 $3,900 $6,300 61.8%
Noor 8 years 130% $4,700 $1,000 $3,700 78.7%
All three $31,400 $15,200 $16,200 51.6%

Noor's car was eight years old and her loan was 130% of what it was worth, so her car fetched little next to what she owed. Ivy's was a year old and her loan was 85% of its value. Older cars and bigger loans leave less to recover.

For the group, add the dollars first: $16,200 / $31,400 = 51.6%. Averaging the three percentages gives 59.4%, as if Noor's small loan weighed as much as Ivy's.

How the two fit together

$31,400 of the $200,000 lent was charged off: 15.7%. 51.6% of that was lost. 15.7% x 51.6% = 8.1%, the cumulative net loss. A pool can lose more because more loans go bad, or because each bad loan loses more.

The real numbers

Subprime auto loans (FICO 300-659 at origination) made in the third quarter of 2024, by month 24, across every issuer in our data:

Amount
Original balance $5.34 billion
Charged off $626.5 million
Recovered $258.6 million
Net loss $367.9 million
Cumulative net loss 6.9%
Loss severity at month 24 58.7%

Across the quarters since 2017, subprime cumulative net loss at month 24 ran from 1.9% (2020 Q1) to 7.7% (2022 Q2).

Severity by collateral, loans made in 2017-2018 that were charged off (dollars added first; Mercedes-Benz is left out because it reports only gross losses):

Loan-to-value <65% 65-79% 80-89% 90-94% 95-99% 100-104% 105-114% 115-119% 120-129% 130%+
Subprime 27.5% 35.1% 40.5% 43.8% 45.8% 46.9% 49.0% 51.3% 52.3% 53.0%
Prime 21.5% 23.7% 27.6% 32.6% 32.8% 34.7% 38.6% 40.8% 42.5% 44.0%
Car age when bought New 1 yr 2 yrs 3 yrs 4 yrs 5+ yrs
Subprime 44.1% 47.3% 49.0% 50.5% 53.2% 57.3%
Prime 36.5% 41.4% 43.3% 43.0% 48.4% 52.1%

Common pitfalls

  • Too young to compare. Our data runs through September 2026. Loans made in January 2025 are 21 months old, so they have no month-24 figure yet. We leave them blank. Showing 0% would make the newest loans look perfect.
  • Gross or net. Gross loss counts charge-offs before anything is recovered; net loss subtracts recoveries. For the subprime loans above, gross loss was 11.7% and net loss 6.9%. Check which one a chart shows: our dashboard's Cumulative Loss page shows gross loss.
  • Recoveries as reported. We count recoveries as the servicer reports them, before repossession and auction costs are taken out. Net of those costs the loss would be larger.
  • Recoveries arrive late. A car is sold months after the charge-off, so a young group's severity reads high until its recoveries come in. Compare groups at the same age.
  • Averages of percentages. Add the dollars, then divide. An average of loan-level or pool-level percentages lets small loans count as much as big ones.

Where to see it

Source: LoanTape, SEC Form ABS-EE loan-level data, through September 2026.