Explainers  /  6 of 20

Ghost curves and vintage ranks

Reading this year's vintage against faded past vintages, and its rank at month 12 and month 24.

One vintage's loss curve means little on its own. Ghost curves draw the past vintages faintly behind it, so you can see where it sits in its own history. A vintage rank turns that into a place: read every vintage at the same month on book, sort them, and see where this one lands.

Seven vintages

Seven made-up quarterly vintages, with cumulative net loss as a share of what was lent (the measure from the cumulative net loss explainer):

Vintage Month 12 Month 24
2021 Q1 1.0% 2.6%
2021 Q3 1.4% 3.1%
2022 Q1 2.1% 4.6%
2022 Q3 1.8% 4.0%
2023 Q1 1.6% 3.5%
2023 Q3 1.9% 4.2%
2024 Q1 2.3% not yet (month 15)

On its own, 2023 Q3 at 1.9% by month 12 is just a number. Drawn against the ghosts, it sits near the top of the pack.

The rank at month 12 and month 24

Read every curve at month 12 and sort, highest loss first: 2023 Q3 is 3rd of 7.

At month 24, 2024 Q1 has not got there yet, so it is left out (see the censoring explainer). Among the 6 that have, 2023 Q3 is 2nd of 6.

Rank at month 24 Vintage Month 24
1 2022 Q1 4.6%
2 2023 Q3 4.2%
3 2022 Q3 4.0%
4 2023 Q1 3.5%
5 2021 Q3 3.1%
6 2021 Q1 2.6%

A rank hides the size of the gap: 2023 Q3 is 0.4 points behind 2022 Q1 and 0.2 ahead of 2022 Q3.

The real numbers

Every subprime (FICO 300-659) origination quarter since 2017, cumulative net loss as a share of original balance, through September 2026. The newest quarter to reach month 24 is 2024 Q3.

Month 12 Month 24
2024 Q3 2.3% 6.9%
Its rank 18th of 35 8th of 31
Highest 2022 Q2, 3.3% 2022 Q2, 7.7%

At month 12, 2024 Q3 sat mid-pack. By month 24 it had moved up to 8th of 31: its losses picked up in its second year. The quarter one place above it, 2023 Q4, is only 0.01 points higher, a tie in all but name.

Common pitfalls

  • A rank hides the gap. Places can be fractions of a point apart, or several points. Read the number next to the place.
  • Ranks only at the same month. Rank a vintage against others at a month they have all reached. A young vintage has no rank at months it has not reached, and its rank at month 12 can change by month 24.
  • The field changes. The month-12 ranking has more vintages in it than the month-24 one, so an 8th place in each is not the same position.
  • Highlights are recency, not quality. On our deck pages the newest vintages are coloured so they are easy to find, wherever they fall.

Where to see it

Source: LoanTape, SEC Form ABS-EE loan-level data, through September 2026. Quarterly vintages, FICO 300-659 at origination, all issuers.